It is more and more difficult to find the valuable required scientific papers accurately and efficiently on Internet, thus a new thesis evaluation method was proposed based on consistency of the title and text to deal with this problem. First of all, the title and text were modeled by eigenvectors respectively. After that, the technique of words similarity was used to calculate the matching-degree of each feature word in title and text vector. The feature word pair was successfully matched if their matching degree was greater than a certain threshold. Then all such matching pairs and their word weights were counted up to calculate the credibility of the title. Based on the hierarchical tree structure of the thesis title, the similarity matching degree of all headings and their corresponding text were calculated by Depth First Traversal (DFT) algorithm, and then the credibility of the paper was evaluated. A case study results prove that the proposed method can realize the scientific papers' credible quality assessment, which makes it be more efficient for readers in paper reading.